Why this book?
Kouzes & Posner focus on leadership and the importance personal and organizational learning. They present ways for leaders to learn as a person and in their leadership roles, extend learning to others in the organization, and provide ways to develop skills in all business and government sectors. Later in the book they identify Marshall Goldsmith’s questions expressed in his book Triggers. There are great questions that deepen our own and others’ reflection called Self-Coaching Actions at the end of the chapters.
Learning Leadership. Kouzes, James & Posner, Barry. (2016) San Francisco: Wiley & Sons.
We need leaders everywhere in the organization no matter what your position is. Lazlo Bock (2009) in his book Work Rules defines leadership as being responsible for contributing ideas to solve problems rather than sitting back and letting only people with titles decide without input. There is a shortage of leadership in the world at all levels
Noel Tichy (1997) in Leadership Engine posits leaders have two main responsibilities. First, be the head learner and two, develop others in the organization as leaders. Learning to be a better leader also enhances your feelings of self-worth and meaningfulness. The authors provide three aspects on leadership.
- Leaders are born and so are you.
- Leadership makes a difference.
- You are already leading, just not frequently enough.
Maybe the questions should be “how do I learn to be a more effective leader?” and “how do I help others develop leadership skills.” Kouzes and Posner, for years, have promoted their five tenets.
- Model the Way
- Inspire a Shared Vision
- Challenge the Process
- Enable Others to Act
- Encourage the Heart
Concerning the first one, people are always watching. That is why modeling is so important. Neuroscience has identified “mirror neurons” that influence behaviors by watching others. The adage by Ralph Waldo Emerson fits, “What you do speaks so loud that I cannot hear what you say.” The other four leadership skills are explained more fully in the book.
Professor Heidi Grant Halvorson at Columbia Business School points out, there’s a vast difference between “being good” and “getting better.” A main goal of this work, as well as SCC is, how do we get better. As the world gets increasingly complex, leaders will need a wide repertoire of strategies and, be able to create new ways of solving problems.
Jan Singer, Spanx, “Never stop learning. If you have it all figured out, you’re dead. You have to be open, and you have to listen and learn. You may feel a bit exhausted from all the learning in college, but find what energizes you and keep learning. The more serious you are about learning, the more questions you should ask.
The authors address some of the myths about leadership that are in our belief system.
THE STRENGTHS MYTH – the strengths approach has been misapplied to mean that you should take on only tasks in which you are strong. The emphasis on strengths has fundamentally discouraged people from challenging themselves to become better leaders. Ignoring feedback about areas that you are not good at, is inconsistent with a lot of research on learning.
THE SELF-RELIANCE MYTH – the best leaders know they can’t do it alone. World-class athletes all have coaches. We all need to engage support in your learning and growth.
THE IT-COMES-NATURALLY MYTH – K. Anders Ericsson, said, “Until most individuals recognize that sustained training and effort is a prerequisite for reaching expert levels of performance, they will continue to misattribute lesser achievement to the lack of natural gifts, and will thus fail to reach their own potential.”
High intelligence does not guarantee great leadership. Many smart people do not possess the social intelligence skills to be successful. Several authors have written that more leaders fail because of relationship issues than book knowledge. Most managers fail in their careers because of poor relationships with their direct reports.
McGill University Management Professor Nancy Adler finds that the best way to access the insights you gain from your experiences is to reflect on them daily. Write down all the ways you can think of that you could become better at asking for feedback. Here are some questions as an example of the Self-Coaching Actions at the end of the chapters.
- What difference do I want to make?
- Are my actions making the difference I want to make?
- Do my actions help bring out the best in myself and others?
In 1986, Charles Garfield wrote in Peak Performers that ‘internal locus of control’ was the main factor in the best performers. This was based on the work of Albert Bandura who researched self-efficacy. Efficacy is defined as the belief you can do something that will make a difference. Teacher efficacy has been shown to be a critical attribute in helping kids learn. It is one of the most important elements in assisting ourselves to learn and to grow while helping others do the same.
Becky Schaar, Google, her personal-best reflection revealed the need to understand “what you deeply believe because people won’t follow you, or even pay much attention to you, if you don’t have strong belief.”
No leader ever made anything extraordinary happen by keeping things the same. Obviously, this involves change. Change usually means risking trying something new. Some questions for leaders to consider are:
- What does the culture have to be for you, the leader, to behave differently or advocate for a new solution?
- How do you create that environment for others?Maintaining the status quo is the breeding ground for mediocrity. PEOPLE DO THEIR BEST WHEN CHALLENGED – Our research shows that:
- Opportunities to challenge the status quo and introduce change open the door to doing one’s best. Challenge is the motivating environment for excellence.
- Challenging opportunities often bring forth skills and abilities that people don’t know they have.
- People who become leaders don’t always seek the challenges they face. Challenges also seek leaders.
To try something new and/or develop a culture that encourages responsible risk-taking requires courage. There are many ways courage shows up in leadership behavior e.g. speaking truth to power, having hard conversations with employees, making the call when times test our values, etc. Peter Block said to us: “The truth is courage is there all the time. Fifty times a day you have to decide whether to move toward what’s hard or difficult or boring or whatever, or whether to try to walk around it and take the easy way out.”
Leaders can change their behavior on their own. Making changes in the organization will involve others. Eric Pan “No matter how capable you are as a leader, you won’t be able to deliver results all by yourself.” Of course, most people look around and try to find out what others have tried, who has been successful, and to be alert to things that did not work. That means we look for others to teach us by giving us more information AND, more importantly, how they achieve good results.
To help with your own career, no matter at what level in the organization you are, “Find someone who has an interest in your development.” Seek out people you learn from and those who would be good mentors. Benjamin Bloom, investigated the development of talent in 120 elite performers – unless there is a long and intensive process of encouragement, nurturance, education, and training, the individuals will not attain extreme levels of capability in these particular fields.
A great piece of advice in this book is – YOU CAN’T IGNORE YOUR WEAKNESSES – If you want to be the best leader you can be, you will have to attend to your weaknesses. You can’t delegate or assign to others those leadership behaviors you aren’t comfortable doing. Ignoring weaknesses doesn’t banish them, and doing so often just makes them worse because they’ll continue to stand in the way of what you want to accomplish. “We have to deal with them so they’ll quit dogging us.” This is another example of courage.
As previously mentioned, the authors suggest SSC behaviors of BUILDING GOOD HABITS WITH ACTIVE QUESTIONS – Marshall Goldsmith, Triggers, asking active questions each day is a “magic move.” “The act of self-questioning—so simple, so misunderstood, so infrequently pursued—changes everything.” In active questioning, Marshall recommends that you start the question with “Did I do my best to . . . followed by whatever action you intend to take.
Some of the results from the active questioning approach versus passive-questions, show positive improvement. The active questions produced twice the effectiveness compared with the passive questions. Examples of active questions and the Self-Coaching Action at the end of the chapter are:
- Did I do my best to remain positive about my abilities today?
- Did I do my best to focus on exciting future possibilities today?
- Did I do my best to challenge and stretch myself today?
- Did I do my best to learn from other people today?
- Did I do my best to practice a new leadership skill today.?
Garfield, C. (1986). Peak performers. New York: Avon Books.
Goldsmith, Marshall. (2015). Triggers. New York: Crown
Tichy. N. (1997). The leadership engine. New York: HarperCollins.